Key Takeaways
- Sunday's mistakes included two holding penalties on returns, an invalid fair catch signal, and a punt that hit a Bengals player and had to be recovered near the goal line.
- The Bengals rank second in the NFL in offensive EPA and 17th on defense, but 20th on special teams.
- They are 28th in special teams penalty yards, with 115 yards given up and just under 1.5 special teams penalties a game. They are 24th in return EPA.
- Rapien's math on the No. 1 seed: 13-4 may be the minimum, which would be the most wins in franchise history. That leaves little room for giveaways.
- The kicking and punting are not the problem. Evan McPherson has been strong all season.
Why it matters now
Rapien's point is that a 20-point win hides these mistakes, and a close game against the Jaguars, Bills or Chiefs would not. If the muffed punt on Sunday bounces the other way, Pittsburgh has the ball inside the 10 with a chance to take the lead. In Week 3, a running-into-the-punter penalty and a fumbled punt helped turn a game the Bengals controlled into a loss.
Marisa Contipelli and Jacob Tissot agreed that the worry is the type of mistake. These are mental errors and penalties from experienced players, which are fixable in a way that a talent gap is not. The segment's ask of special teams coordinator Darrin Simmons was simple: clean it up now.