Skip to main content
Crown Network

First Word with James Rapien

The Bengals Have BIG Expectations... and Winning a Playoff Game ISN'T Enough | BUY or SELL?

· 10:09

At 7-2, is anything short of the AFC Championship Game a disappointment for the Bengals? Two of the three First Word hosts say yes. The crew also backs Zac Taylor for Coach of the Year and debates whether Amarius Mims is already a top-five tackle.

Key Takeaways

  • AFC Championship or bust: James Rapien and Marisa Contipelli buy it. Jacob Tissot sells, saying a playoff win and a loss to an elite team would not be a letdown.
  • Zac Taylor for Coach of the Year: all three buy. The Bengals are 7-2 after missing the playoffs three straight years, and the defense has turned around.
  • A Super Bowl without a consistent run game: the hosts agree the run game has to be efficient, not high volume. Four yards a carry when it matters is enough.
  • Amarius Mims: a top-five pass blocker already, with run blocking still catching up. His PFF run-blocking grades were 89.4 against the Falcons and 82.8 against the Steelers.
  • The hosts expect Joe Burrow to pass his own franchise record of 43 touchdown passes in a season.

How high is the bar?

Rapien's view is that the standard changed when the Bengals traded the 10th pick for Dexter Lawrence, and when Joe Burrow said in May that the goal was a Super Bowl. Contipelli agreed after watching Sunday night: a team that complete, with those expectations, should reach the conference title game.

Tissot was the holdout. He called the Bengals a legitimate contender and said the Super Bowl is the goal, but argued it is hard to get there and a second-round loss to a top seed would not make the season a failure. Rapien did not accept it, pointing out how quickly the window felt open in 2022 and how long it has taken to get back.

Credit for Zac Taylor

The hosts think Taylor gets less credit than other offensive play callers in the Coach of the Year conversation. Their case: if the Bengals reach 13 wins, he should not only be in the race, he should probably win it.

Watch the full episode

More from First Word with James Rapien